the one about the film festival


Hi Reader -

A while back I cancelled our team's ChatGPT subscription. I was terrified everyone would walk out on me. (The whole saga is here.)

Nobody walked out. They opened a terminal instead. Most of them had never seen one, and nobody on our team is an engineer. It was like watching people who'd only ever eaten at McDonald's walk into the kitchen and start cooking.

Soooo now everyone lives in the terminal. Me included. I'm in there 12 to 14 hours a day. Which is great. But "I'm a terminal person" is just "I'm a spreadsheet person" with a darker screen.

You know the lines. "I'm a numbers person." "I'm not really a creative." "That's not my job." Every company has someone who says one of those in a meeting, with total peace in their heart.

I want Renaissance people. (Yes, I just said "Renaissance" about an ad agency. I may have just become THAT guy.)

So last month we ran a film festival. We called it Rollywood, because we are adults.

The rules:

  • One ad per person.
  • Strategists and growth marketers ONLY. Our designers were banned. They took it well. (Mostly.)
  • $50 in credits, max.
  • The subject had to be a client, or a client's industry.

And it had to be made in our own AI agent. We built that one ourselves(rather imaginatively called Launcher), because everything off the shelf, including proven tools like Higgsfield, wasnt quite perfect for what we needed.

We held the premiere on a Friday, with awards and cash prizes, because apparently this is who we are now.

And they made cinematic AI films. Nobody opened Photoshop. Nobody opened After Effects. Not one of the people who entered is a designer.

I can't show you the actual films, since they're about our clients' industries. But here's what they looked like:

Now, about "cinematic."

I said this two emails ago: the six fingers are mostly gone. Anyone can make a realistic person in a realistic kitchen saying realistic things for 15 seconds. It's very photorealistic. It's also slop, because nothing HAPPENS in it.

What's missing is a story. Some drama. Somebody who wants something and doesn't get it for a while. Here's the kind of film I mean. It's called Stephen, and it's three minutes long. We make HUNDREDS of these a month now.

Anywayyy, here's what I took from the festival.

The tool gives you the realistic kitchen. The story has to come from a person. Specifically, a person who knows what your customer is lying awake about at 3am.

That's a strategist's job.

So the people who "aren't really creatives" turned out to be exactly the right people to make the film.

For you, it means the person reading the numbers on your account is the same person shaping the story in your ads. Nothing gets lost in the handoff, because there isn't one.

If you're spending $50k+/month and want your ads made by people like that, reply "FILM" and we'll talk. Or don't. I'm sure the 3 rounds of edits with 5 specialized designers working by hand will turn out perfectly fine.

Later,
Shamanth

P.S. Here are some goodies from our socials:

​Is your creative team slow, or is the work stuck between tools?​

​How to hit 1000% ROAS. Every single time.​

​Meta tells you your cost per trial. It can't tell you your cost per paying user.​

​We asked our designers to stop using CapCut, After Effects and Photoshop​

​Your product isn't 'too mature to grow'​

​Is your competitor research telling you what to test next, or just sending you into AI tagging hell?​

​Your AI character looks the same in every shot. So why does the ad still feel wrong?​

​How do you measure audience diversity?​

Welcome to Intelligent Artifice, your weekly dose of insights to help you win with performance marketing in a Generative AI world.

Intelligent Artifice features hard won insights from the front-lines of performance marketing in a Generative AI world - delivered straight into your inbox. For free.

Read more from Welcome to Intelligent Artifice, your weekly dose of insights to help you win with performance marketing in a Generative AI world.

Hi Reader - "It is remarkable how much long-term advantage people like us have gotten by trying to be consistently not stupid instead of trying to be very intelligent." That's Charlie Munger, Warren Buffett's partner. Everyone in advertising is hunting the whale (or unicorn, or outlier - pick your metaphor of choice). You know the one. The ad that eats your budget, makes your year, and gets you high-fiving your CFO. Soooo every quarter somebody uncaps a marker and says "what's our big swing?"...

Hi Reader - There's a robot in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy called Marvin. Full name: Marvin the Paranoid Android. He's the smartest thing in the universe, and he's miserable about it. In one scene, he tells a mattress he's thirty billion times smarter than it is. To prove it, he runs a little test. "Think of a number, any number." "Er, five." "Wrong. You see?" The mattress comes away very impressed. I think about that scene a lot when we use AI to analyze ads. Because the analysis...

Hi Reader - Years ago, I was working on a word game, and we were killing it in the US. So we ran an experiment in the UK. After all, they speak English too, right? I think it was George Bernard Shaw who said: England and America are two countries divided by a common language. (Whoever it was that said it, I was about to prove it.) Anywayyy for our word game, the UK did even better than the US. CPI was strong. Cost per first puzzle played was strong. D1 ROAS was extremely strong, and D7 held...