The day your ‘best’ ad stops working


Hi Reader

Every account has one.

The legacy winner.

That ad that’s held the crown for 18 months straight.

Still shows green in the dashboards.

Still delivers ‘OK’ metrics.

Still feels… safe.

Everyone kinda hates it tho.

‘cos sometimes a “winning” ad is what’s holding you back.

…it’s a local maxima - a ceiling that is blocking your growth.


This kids’ app we’d been working with had scaled hard.

Their top ad had crushed for months: and new variants just couldn’t beat it.

Every week, the same outcome:

New ads died early.

The control kept winning.

Costs creep up.

And growth slows down.

Nobody’s fault.

But at some point, it’s time to break the pattern.


So that’s what we did.

We stripped everything back.

Rebuilt the process with our AI-powered strategy.

Using BruteForce AI to dive deep into what makes ads ‘tick’

…and building on these learnings, step by step, ad by ad.

We made small bets.

Every format. Every style.

Every message. And we shipped. Weekly.

Tested these outside of the container of the top ad.


A few weeks in…

Something shifted.

✅ Better clickthroughs

✅ Higher thumbstop rate

✅ Cost per trial started dropping

✅ A new winner emerged - first in our ‘warm up’ campaign.

…and then in our scale campaign. FINALLY.

It finally beat the legacy ad.

Quietly, without drama.

Just the result of dozens of small learnings compounding.

As their founder said in our case study:

We’ve been working with Rocketship HQ for over 3 years, and they’ve consistently helped us level up our growth game.

We had a long-time winning ad that nothing could beat. We did a lot of testing, but performance had plateaued. That’s when RocketShip brought in a new AI-powered creative strategy, one that focused on weekly testing, emotional storytelling, and learnings from high-performing apps.

Within just 2 months, we finally beat our ‘untouchable’ top ad. Not just once, but with multiple new creatives. Our CTR jumped, conversion rates improved, and trial costs dropped. But more importantly, we’ve now got a repeatable system for testing and winning, not just one lucky hit.


We didn’t crack the code on day one.

We just stopped trying to find lightning in a bottle: and started running the playbook that created storm clouds.

If you spend $50k+/mo and have got an old ad still “working” but growth has flatlined…

Let’s talk.

Reply with “RESET” and I’ll walk you through how we help you beat the winner: without blowing everything up.

Later,

Shamanth

Welcome to Intelligent Artifice, your weekly dose of insights to help you win with performance marketing in a Generative AI world.

Intelligent Artifice features hard won insights from the front-lines of performance marketing in a Generative AI world - delivered straight into your inbox. For free.

Read more from Welcome to Intelligent Artifice, your weekly dose of insights to help you win with performance marketing in a Generative AI world.

Hey Reader — Ever built the world’s most profitable store on top of a volcano? That’s what we did. Didn’t know it at the time. Picture this. Day three of a $10k/day spend streak. Dashboard’s on fire. And not the good kind. CPAs are spiking. ROAS is cratering. The client’s blowing up our Slack. I'm staring at the screen like… WHAT IS HAPPENING. WTF WTF WTF is this. 24 hours earlier, everything was beautiful. 48 hours earlier, we were high-fiving. Now we’re panic-pulling budgets back to...

Hey Reader Had a call with a subscription app’s growth team recently. Preparing for the Q5 CPM crash. ..the big spike in January. New Year New You etc. They wanted to go big. They were ready to scale. But they weren't feeling it. Creative tests werent translating to performance. Every week, they were trying to come up with completely new ad concepts. New hooks. New angles. New everything. 20 different ideas. 20 directions. And nothing was landing. Performance was flat. CPAs were climbing....

Hey Reader - Many moons ago, I read this book about Miyamoto Musashi. Legendary Japanese swordsman. In it, two swordsmen travel to challenge an old master named Yagyu Sekishusai. This dude was the real deal. The Shogun's weapons instructor. But he doesn't accept challenges anymore. ‘cos he's retired now - and aint got time for the young ‘uns. So instead of fighting, he sends each of them a single cut peony flower. One swordsman, a guy named Yoshioka, is insulted. He wanted a duel. Not a...